District Court of Appeal of Florida June 9, 1983, No. 83-480 (Cavalere v. Graham)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-06-1983

COBB, Judge.

This is the second appearance before this court of the same matter. The facts giving rise to this controversy show that the respondent, John Russell Graham, was a passenger in an automobile driven by David T. Cavalere, owned by Virginia E. Cavalere, and insured by Allstate Insurance Company, the latter three parties being the petitioners for certiorari herein and in the prior petition resulting in our opinion in Cavalere v. Graham, 423 So.2d 428 (Fla. 5th DCA 1982).

As a result of the collision between the Cavalere vehicle and another, Graham sued the Cavaleres and Allstate. These defendants answered by claiming accord and satisfaction in that Graham’s claim had been settled. Graham filed an amended reply to the affirmative defense, which purported to assert fraud, estoppel, and failure of consideration in regard to the alleged release. The fraud alleged by Graham was that Allstate did not tell him how bad his injuries were and settled his claim for less than it was worth. The alleged estoppel was that Graham was without counsel at the time *757and Allstate was more knowledgeable about the settlement of claims than he was, and knew his claim was worth more than he was paid, based on the factor of liability and the extent of his injuries. Graham also claimed a failure of consideration on the basis that he returned the money paid to him for the release some eight days after its execution.

With the issues thus framed, Graham, through discovery, sought production of Allstate’s complete file pertaining to his claim and propounded questions to Allstate’s investigator pertaining to that defendant’s work product. The trial judge, the Honorable Frederick Pfeiffer, entered an order, over defense objection, granting the discovery and the petitioners sought certiorari review from that order.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.