District Court of Appeal of Florida July 13, 1983, No. AO-343 (Powell v. Powell)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-07-1983

JOANOS, Judge.

Edward Powell appeals a final judgment awarding child support for his two dependent children whose custody is with their mother, Janet Powell. Edward argues that the trial court’s use of a document entitled, “Proposal of Guidelines for Awarding Child Support” (Guidelines) without giving him an opportunity to review or challenge it, violates Section 90.204(3), Florida Statutes (1981) and Section 61.13(1), Florida Statutes (1981). We agree and reverse.

The Guidelines is a document that was developed by a committee appointed by the Eighth Judicial Bar Association. It provides a suggested formula for the award of child support in domestic cases.1

*1375While there is no transcribed record of the child support hearing, the statement of evidence shows that prior to announcing the trial court’s decision, Judge Chance asked Edward’s attorney, Brown, if he was familiar with the Guidelines. Brown answered that he was unaware of any such guidelines. Judge Chance then stated that no evidence had been presented to justify any deviation from the Guidelines and proceeded to award child support using the Guidelines.

While the use of a uniform scale or formula may very well be a very fair and reasonable way to determine child support, we can find no support currently under Florida law for use of the Guidelines in the manner utilized by the trial court. Section 90.204(3), Florida Statutes (1981) requires that “[i]f a court resorts to any documentary source of information not received in open court, the court shall make the information and its source a part of the record in the action and shall afford each party reasonable opportunity to challenge such information, and to offer additional information, before judicial notice of the matter is taken.” Resort to the Guidelines without making them part of the record or allowing Edward an opportunity to challenge them is clearly violative of Section 90.204(3). Section 61.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.