Nevada Supreme Court May 19, 1983, No. 14568 (Sheriff v. Potter)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-05-1983

*390OPINION

Per Curiam:

An information charged respondent Richard Potter (Potter) with two counts of robbery, a felony (NRS 200.380). The district court granted a pretrial petition for writ of habeas corpus on the ground that there was not sufficient evidence before the magistrate to establish probable cause to believe that Potter had committed the offense charged in the second count. Appellant Sheriff of Clark County has appealed from the order granting the petition. We reverse.

This court’s review is limited to whether the district court committed substantial error in determining that there was no probable cause. Sheriff v. Provenza, 97 Nev. 346, 630 P.2d 265 (1981).

The evidence before the magistrate consisted solely of preliminary hearing testimony from Lora Estrada (Estrada), one of the two alleged victims. The substance of her testimony is as follows. On September 3, 1982, shortly after ten o’clock at night, Estrada was hitchhiking with Lois Toledo (Toledo) in Las Vegas. The two women were picked up by two men identified at the hearing as Potter and his co-defendant Ricky Foote (Foote), who was driving. The four agreed that Toledo would supply gas money and the men would drive both women first to the Western Union office and then to the airport. After *391stopping at the Western Union office so that Toledo could obtain money for a flight to California, the men stopped at a park where they held a whispered conversation outside the car while the women waited inside. Upon leaving the park, the men did not proceed to the airport, but instead drove onto a dirt road leading to a desert dump. Foote stopped the car and Potter got out of the front passenger seat, opened the right rear door, and “jumped” into the back seat on Estrada’s lap. Potter then pushed Toledo into the front seat while Foote pulled her by the hair. Estrada heard Foote yell to Potter to “[c]heck all of the pockets.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.