Virginia Beach County Circuit Court August 3, 1983, Case No. (Law) 11,737 (Cutchin v. Gordon Harper Harley Davidson Sales, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-08-1983

By JUDGE BERNARD G. BARROW

This is a products liability suit seeking damages for personal injuries arising out of a motorcycle accident. A jury returned verdicts against both the motorcycle’s manufacturer and its dealer who have now moved to set aside the verdicts. These motions raise three issues: (1) Was the evidence at trial sufficient for the jury to determine that the alleged defect próximately caused the accident injuring the plaintiff? (2) Was a manufacturer’s service bulletin describing the defect admissible into evidence? (3) Did the dealer exclude any warranty to the plaintiff by virtue of a provision in its Bill of Sale? I have concluded that the defendants’ motions to set aside the jury verdicts should be denied.

(1) Sufficiency of the Evidence

The accident occurred about 11:30 p.m. on August 31, 1979. The plaintiff, riding his motorcycle, entered a curve to the left and attempted to apply his rear brakes. He discovered that the rear brakes would not *113apply. He downshifted the transmission to second gear and applied his front wheel brakes. The rear of the motorcycle "jumped to the right a little bit" and skidded into the left rear corner of a car parked on the right side of the street. The left side of the motorcycle fell to the ground, but not before the plaintiff’s body was struck between the motorcycle and the car. He suffered multiple injuries including a crushing injury to his right lower leg which resulted in its amputation approximately three inches below his knee.

The plaintiff had purchased the motorcycle from the defendant, Gordon Harper Harley Davidson Sales, Inc. (Gordon Harper) on April 16, 1979. The motorcycle had been manufactured by the defendant, AMF, Incorporated, trading as Harley-Davidson Motor Company, Inc., (Harley-Davidson).

Between its purchase and the date of the accident the plaintiff experienced problems with the brakes, including the rear brake pedal being hard to push down, squealing of the brakes, and loss of brake fluid.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.