District Court, W.D. Pennsylvania July 14, 1983, Civ. A. No. 82-683 (C.B.H. Resources, Inc. v. Mars Forging Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-07-1983

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

COHILL, District Judge.

Introduction

This case is before us on the defendants’ Motion for Involuntary Dismissal Under Fed.R.Civ.P. 41(b) or for Sanctions. Our findings of fact are based upon hearings conducted on March 10, 1983 and April 14, 1983, as well as several affidavits filed in connection with this motion, and the depositions already included in the file. While we recognize that dismissal with prejudice is an extremely harsh remedy for violations of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure by litigants, see Harris v. Cuyler, 664 F.2d 388 (3d Cir.1981), we are satisfied that the conduct of plaintiff’s president and majority stockholder in this case is sufficiently egregious to justify such a ruling.

Findings of Fact

This action was commenced on April 22, 1982 by C.B.H. Resources, Inc., to recover damages from an alleged breach of an exclusive distributorship. The plaintiff, a Kentucky corporation owned mainly by Cecil Clifford, alleged that it was given the exclusive right to distribute a product manufactured by the defendant (referred to as “sucker rods” or “oil pumping stems”) within a 600 mile radius of Elizabethtown, Kentucky. (We will refer to the defendant in the singular because the two names in the caption appear to have done business as a single economic entity.)

Based on the discovery conducted through the early part of 1983, the plaintiff’s claim of an exclusive distributorship appeared to rest primarily on conversations which took place between March of 1981 and May of 1981 between Robert Woodings, the controlling owner of the defendant, Timothy Houlihan, then sales director for the defendant, and Cecil Clifford, president of the plaintiff. See Deposition of Cecil Clifford at 32 (November 11, 1982). From March of 1981 until he left the employ of the defendant in January of 1982, Mr. Houlihan appears to have been the main contact between plaintiff and defendant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.