Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit April 11, 1983, No. 82-5041 (R.C. Hilton Associates, Inc. v. Stan Musial & Biggie's Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-04-1983
GODBOLD, Chief Judge:
A real estate broker, R.C. Hilton Associates, Inc., brought this action to recover a *908commission on the sale of a hotel. Initially Hilton’s agent visited the hotel to determine whether it was for sale. An agent of Stan Musial & Biggie’s, Inc. (Musial), the owner, advised Hilton that the hotel might be for sale for $4.25 million, net to owner. Musial stated that it did not intend to pay any sales commission and that Hilton would have to make arrangements for its commission with the buyer. Hilton subsequently initiated discussions between Musial and Edward Stern. After a short period of negotiations (in which Hilton did not participate) Stern agreed to purchase the hotel for $4.12 million. No commission was paid to Hilton.
Hilton brought suit against Musial and Stern in Florida state court. The defendants removed the case to federal court based on diversity.
The complaint contains three counts: (1) a breach of contract action against Musial; (2) a claim of tortious interference with a business contract against Stern; and (3) an unjust enrichment claim against Musial for the value of services rendered. The case was referred to a United States Magistrate acting as a special master pursuant to Fed. R.Civ.P. 53. After a non jury trial the magistrate made findings of fact and conclusions of law and recommended that judgment be entered against Hilton on all counts. The district court adopted and confirmed the magistrate’s findings and conclusions. We affirm.
The district court ruled that Hilton had neither an express nor implied contract with Musial. Hilton argues that the district court’s conclusion that no contract existed is inconsistent with its findings of fact. The court found that Musial told Hilton that “anything over $4.25 million is yours.” Hilton contends that in making this statement Musial agreed to pay a commission. To support this contention Hilton relies on the court’s statement that “since the sale price was less than [$4.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit