Court of Appeals for the First Circuit December 14, 1983, Nos. 82-1482, 82-1531 (Security Title & Guaranty Co. v. Mid-Cape Realty, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-12-1983
SKINNER, District Judge,
This action arises out of a dispute concerning land in Harwich, Massachusetts which was at one time owned by Susan Underwood.
The following chronology is drawn from the findings of the district judge, which we deem supported by the evidence. On October 15, 1917, Susan Underwood sold the six-acre lot to Clarence Burgess. This transaction, which is the first link of one of two purported chains of title, was recorded on November 3, 1926, but the deed did not correctly describe the lot because one of the courses was reversed. Burgess subsequently conveyed title to various members of the Rose family, Reginald Rose conveyed the property to Elizabeth Marsh on May 31, 1972 for $22,000. The description of the land in Marsh’s deed is the same as the one in the original deed to Burgess.
The second purported chain of title begins with the death of Susan Underwood. Eleanor Underwood Mahoney, a residual devisee of Susan Underwood, believed that she had inherited the lot even though the inventory of assets filed in connection with the probate of Susan Underwood’s will indicated that she owned no real estate at the time of her death. In August, 1967, Mahoney made a new plan of the lot; this plan became the basis for a subsequent deed description which was correct.
On March 24, 1972, Louis Handler, the owner of land abutting the lot, paid Mahoney $2,300 for the property. Robert Hall, Handler’s attorney, attempted to obtain an abstract of the property for Handler, but, after having some difficulty, suggested that Handler obtain a title examiner or another attorney for the task. After further discussion with Hall, Handler applied to a local bank for a mortgage loan. The bank employed its attorney, Alan T. Hunt, to search the title. Mr. Hunt searched the property and informed the bank that the title was sufficient to serve as security for a mortgage.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit