Court of Appeals for the First Circuit November 1, 1983, Nos. 83-1147 thru 83-1150 (Aubin v. Fudala)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-11-1983

BREYER, Circuit Judge.

The legal questions that plaintiffs and defendants raise in their cross-appeals in this “civil rights/tort” case are for the most part rooted in the facts and the evidence produced at trial. That is to say, the answers to the parties’ legal claims — e.g. that the district court should have given certain instructions, that it should have directed verdicts on certain issues but not others — can be determined only by a study of the record. We have conducted that study and we conclude that the judgments of the district court should be affirmed. This opinion, rather than reiterating all the relevant facts, testimony and arguments, will simply set forth enough trial-related information to indicate to the parties the reasoning on which our conclusion rests.

I

The suit underlying this appeal is a combined “federal civil rights/state negligence” action that Maurice and Normande Aubin and their two sons, Lionel and Norman, brought against the New Hampshire town of Bedford, its police chief (Audette), four police officers (Fudala, Biron, Morency, Abood) and a New Hampshire state trooper (Meaneg). The claims arose out of the fact that the police shot Lionel Aubin by mistake while investigating a robbery with which he had absolutely no connection. Many of the surrounding facts are disputed; but for purposes of this appeal, we can take the following as a rough description of what is either agreed upon or at least firmly established.

On New Year’s Eve, 1979, someone called the Bedford Police Department and reported a burglary in progress at the home of the Kuzakis’, exact address unknown. The police dispatcher, apparently knowing the approximate location, said to Officer Fudala, “Stan, we’ve got a burglary in progress at the Kuzakis residence, Palomino and Whitmore,” and he broadcast that information to policemen Biron and Abood. Trooper Meaney received the same broadcast and went to the scene, arriving there first.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.