Hawaii Supreme Court January 11, 1984, NO. 9057 (Maui Land & Pineapple Company, Inc. v. Dillingham Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-01-1984

*5

OPINION OF THE COURT BY

NAKAMURA, J.

The issue is whether the conveyance of a lease by the Dillingham Corporation (Dillingham or the corporation) to Ala Moana Hawaii Properties (Ala Moana), a limited partnership whose limited partners are the corporation’s stockholders, was an “assignment” for purposes of Paragraph 15(a) of the lease agreement between Dillingham and the Maui Land and Pineapple Company, Inc. (Maui Land). The Circuit Court of the Second Circuit held that the transfer, effected as part of a plan to liquidate Dillingham’s commercial real estate operating assets in Hawaii, “constitute[d] an assignment” and awarded Maui Land summary judgment in the declaratory action brought against Dillingham and Ala Moana. But we think the court’s summary disposition of the question was improper, inasmuch as the crucial language of Paragraph 15(a) can be read to sustain either the position of the plaintiff or the defendants’ thesis that the paragraph did not apply to the transaction and there was no evidence of its intended meaning. Thus, we vacate the judgment and remand the case for trial.

I.

The controversy at bar stems from the Plan of Partial Liquidation adopted by Dillingham’s stockholders on June 30, 1981 upon recommendation of the corporation’s Board of Directors. The plan’s purpose was “to terminate . .. [Dillingham’s] commercial real estate development, management, and ownership activities in Hawaii and enable ... [stockholders] to receive substantially all of the net proceeds . . . from the disposition of the assets related to such activities.” One of the properties proposed for liquidation was the

*6

Kaahumanu Shopping Center at Kahului, Maui, which the corporation had constructed on land owned by Maui Land pursuant to a “Lease”

1

executed on August 31, 1971.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.