Supreme Court of South Carolina November 26, 1984, 22188 (State v. McClellan)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-11-1984

Chandler, Justice:

This appeal is from Appellant’s conviction on one count of criminal sexual conduct in the second degree.

We affirm.

Appellant contends the trial judge erred, first in admitting testimony from the prosecutrix, his daughter, and her sisters regarding prior bad acts, and second, in admitting opinion testimony from a lay witness: We disagree.

FACTS

Appellant was indicted on one count of criminal sexual conduct against his youngest daughter, age 15. All three daughters testified concerning the pattern of this and prior attacks. According to them, these attacks commenced about their twelfth birthday, at which time Appellant began entering their bedroom late at night, waking them, and taking one of them to his bedroom. There he would explain the Biblical verse that children are to “Honor thy Father”, and would also indicate he was teaching them how to be with their husbands. The method of attack was common to all three daughters.

None of the daughters reported these incidents until they read a news article which informed the public of available assistance from DSS in such matters. Appellant’s daughters then made a joint decision to report the crimes.

Appellant presented an alibi defense. He testified that while his live-in girlfriend was at work, he spent the night in question with another woman.

PRIOR BAD ACTS

Evidence of prior bad acts is not admissible to prove the crime for which a defendant is charged unless it establishes: (1) motive; (2) intent; (3) absence of mistake or accident; (4) a common scheme or plan; or (5) the identity of the person charged.

State v. Lyle,

125 S. C. 406, 118 S. E. 803 (1923);

State v. Stokes,

279 S. C. 191, 304 S. E. (2d) 814 (1983). The trial judge admitted the daughters’ testimony concerning prior misconduct as evidence of a common scheme or plan.

*392

In.

State v. Whitener,

228 S. C. 244, 89 S. E.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.