Court of Appeals of Wisconsin August 22, 1984, 83-1936 (Kozak v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-08-1984

SCOTT, C.J.

Charlotte and Edward L. Kozak appeal from a judgment dismissing their claim against the United States Fidelity and Guaranty Company (USF&G) on the merits. The issue is whether an exclusionary clause excepting “wrongful conversion and embezzlement” from an insurance policy covering loss by theft is ambiguous as applied to a farm tenant who made an

*465

unauthorized sale of cattle and appropriated the proceeds for his own use. Because we find that the exclusionary clause is ambiguous, we conclude that it does not defeat the Kozaks’ claim under the policy. Accordingly, we reverse.

Charlotte and Edward L. Kozak (Kozaks) are the owners of a farm in East Troy, Wisconsin. They entered into a livestock share lease with Eugene A. Nelson providing that Nelson live and work on the farm and providing for joint ownership of fifty-six dairy cattle. The lease specifically provided that any purchase or sale of the jointly owned property was to be made by mutual agreement. Without the knowledge or agreement of the Kozaks, Nelson sold a total of forty-nine cattle and appropriated the proceeds for his own use.

The Kozaks filed a claim for theft loss under a Farm-owners-Ranchowners Policy issued by USF&G. USF&G denied liability and moved for summary judgment based on the following portion of the policy:

PERILS INSURED AGAINST

This policy under this form insures against direct loss to the property covered by the following perils, subject to the conditions herein and of the policy of which this form is made a part.

9. THEFT, meaning any act of stealing or attempt thereat. With respect to this peril, this policy does not apply to loss:

c. by wrongful conversion and embezzlement; . . . .

USF&G’s motion for summary judgment was denied.

1

A trial was held to the court, and judgment was entered

*466

dismissing the Kozaks’ claim on the merits.

2

The Kozaks appeal.

We have not found any Wisconsin cases that construe the policy terms at issue in this case under similar facts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.