Court of Appeals of Oregon March 27, 1985, 83-04-31561 83-05-32484 CA A30640 (Control) CA A30641 (State v. Haywood)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-03-1985

*8

GILLETTE, J.

In these consolidated criminal appeals, defendant asserts that his various sentences on charges of robbery, rape and kidnapping were excessive, cruel and unusual or that, in the alternative, the trial court lacked the authority to direct that certain of the sentences be served consecutively. As to the former claim, we find no error.

State v. Dinkel,

34 Or App 375, 579 P2d 245 (1978). As to the specific question of authority to impose consecutive sentences, we adhere to the often-stated view that circuit courts have such authority.

See State v. Jones,

250 Or 59, 440 P2d 374 (1968).

One final point requires consideration. The state has raised an issue in its brief which we are compelled to address. The issue revolves around our recent decision in

State v. Hardesty,

68 Or App 591, 682 P2d 824, (1984),

aff’d

298 Or 616, 695 P2d 569 (1985), and involves the state’s disagreement with our holding in that case,

1

in which we interpreted the provisions of ORS 161.610(5), dictating the imposition of a mandatory minimum sentence for persons convicted of a felony while using a firearm.

2

In

Hardesty,

defendant was convicted on two counts of robbery in the first degree and one count of rape in the first degree. The trial court sentenced defendant to 20 years for each conviction and imposed a mandatory minimum sentence of five years on each conviction pursuant to ORS 161.610. The court ordered the mandatory minimum sentences for robbery

*9

to be served concurrently with each other but consecutively to a mandatory minimum for the rape conviction, resulting in a total minimum period of incarceration of 10 years. Defendant argued on appeal that ORS 161.610 allowed only one five-year minimum to be imposed when a defendant is convicted of more than one felony during the course of a “single criminal episode.”

We limited our analysis in

Hardesty

to the narrow issue of “whether ORS 161.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.