Idaho Supreme Court March 26, 1985, 15456 (Burns v. Nyberg)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-03-1985

combined-opinion

697 P.2d 1165 (1985) 108 Idaho 151 Anthony BURNS, Claimant-Appellant, v. Herbert NYBERG, Employer, Defendant-Respondent. No. 15456. Supreme Court of Idaho. March 26, 1985. *1166 John W. Gunn, Caldwell, for claimant-appellant. William F. Gigray, Jr. and R. Scott Pasley, Caldwell, for defendant-respondent. HUNTLEY, Justice. Nyberg, who resides in California, hired Burns to manage an apartment unit in Caldwell, Idaho. After several months, Burns suffered a back injury while moving railroad ties in the apartment parking lot. Two months after that Burns was terminated as manager of the apartment, the reasons stated in Nyberg's dismissal letter being that Burns failed to follow prudent maintenance practices; that rent receipts were forwarded late; and that maintenance receipts were not forwarded with the monthly reports. Burns then filed a Worker's Compensation application. Nyberg resisted the claim, contending that Burns was an independent contractor, not an employee, and that his injury occurred outside the course of his employment. Before Burns was hired, Nyberg had employed Frank Woomer as manager under written contract. The contract with Woomer recited that Woomer was an independent contractor. When Woomer quit he recommended to Nyberg that Burns succeed him, since Burns had done some work for Woomer while Woomer was manager. Burns and Nyberg had no written agreement, but Nyberg contends that Burns understood and agreed that the terms of the written agreement under which Woomer had worked would also apply to Burns. Burns' duties involved renting property to tenants when vacancies occurred, collecting rent, performing minor maintenance, *1167 and cleaning the apartments and maintaining the grounds. He was to submit a monthly report to Nyberg showing the amounts collected, funds expended while performing his work, and the total amount remitted to Nyberg. A $200 operating account was established to purchase supplies and pay minor expenses.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.