Court of Appeals of Oregon April 10, 1985, DA 275090; CA A33056 (State v. Dugger)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-04-1985
*111
RICHARDSON, J.
Defendant publicly exposed his genitals while he was in the Frederick & Nelson department store, and he was charged with public indecency. ORS 163.465. He entered into a civil compromise with the store’s management pursuant to ORS 135.703
et seq.,
and the trial court dismissed the charge. The state appeals from the dismissal. We reverse.
ORS 135.703 provides:
“When a defendant is charged with a crime punishable as a misdemeanor for which the person injured by the act constituting the crime has a remedy by a civil action, the crime may be compromised, as provided in ORS 135.705, except when it was committed:
“(1) By or upon a peace officer while in the execution of the duties of his office;
“(2) Riotously; or
“(3) With an intent to commit a crime punishable only as a felony.”
The state argues that public indecency is not the kind of offense to which ORS 135.703 applies, because the statute is limited to “cases in which the person injured by the act constituting the crime has a civil action remedy. Public indecency is not such a crime.” The problem with the state’s argument is that it does not go far enough. It is virtually unimaginable that
any
crime
cannot
produce
some
injury that is redressable through a civil action. Here, for example, the store
could
have lost business or suffered other compensable injury as a result of defendant’s act. In our view, the issue is whether the statute applies to a criminal act that can produce a civilly redressable injury if that injury is not the sole consequence of the act and is incidental at most to the legislature’s objective in criminalizing the act.
In
State v. Yos,
71 Or App 57, 691 P2d 508 (1984), decided while this appeal was pending, we held that a charge of reckless driving was properly dismissed by the trial court after the defendant had “entered into a civil compromise with the person whose auto he had struck” while driving recklessly. We explained:
“The civil compromise statute, ORS 135.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit