Arizona Supreme Court April 24, 1985, 17607-SA (Summerfield v. Superior Court, Maricopa Cty.)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-04-1985
FELDMAN, Justice.
This case presents the question of whether a wrongful death action can be maintained by the Summerfields (plaintiffs), the parents of a viable fetus that was stillborn as a result of alleged medical malpractice by the respondent real parties in interest (defendants). The trial court granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss the wrongful death count on the authority of
Kilmer v. Hicks,
22 Ariz.App. 552, 529 P.2d 706 (1974), a case which held: 1) that no common law right existed for recovery, and 2) that a viable fetus was not a “person” as that word is used in A.R.S. § 12-611, the statute which authorizes the institution of a damage action against one whose “wrongful act, neglect or default” causes the “death of a person.” Plaintiffs then filed this special action, asking us either to distinguish
Kilmer
on its facts or to overrule it.
SPECIAL ACTION RELIEF
In Arizona relief by “Special Action” replaces that which was previously obtained by use of prerogative writs such as certiorari, mandamus, and prohibition. Rule 1, Ariz.R.P.Sp.Act., 17A A.R.S. We generally accept jurisdiction of petitions for special action only where the issues raised are such that “justice cannot be satisfactorily obtained by other means.”
King v. Superior Court,
138 Ariz. 147, 149, 673 P.2d 787, 789 (1983). In the situation at bench, there are several pending cases in the superior courts which present the same issue. Normal appellate procedures will result in unnecessary cost and delay to all litigants.
See State v. Superior Court,
123 Ariz. 324, 329-30, 599 P.2d 777, 782-83 (1979). The question presented is a clear issue of law with obvious statewide significance. . The congruence of these factors militates in favor of our accepting jurisdiction.
See State ex rel. Corbin v. Pickrell,
136 Ariz. 589, 591, 667 P.2d 1304, 1306
*470
(1983). We therefore take jurisdiction pursuant to Ariz. Const. art. 6, § 5(4), and Rule 1, Ariz.R.P.Sp.Act., 17A A.R.S.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit