Oregon Supreme Court April 23, 1985, TC 131,718, CA A26533, SC S30895 (Staiger v. Burkhart)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-04-1985
*51
LENT, J.
The issue is whether a motor vehicle liability insurer is entitled to an offset against its liability policy limits for the sum it has paid to an injured person as personal injury protection (PIP) benefits.
1
We hold that the insurer is not entitled to the offset.
Plaintiffs
2
were passengers in a motor vehicle operated by defendant Lisa Burkhart in 1980. The vehicle was involved in a collision with another vehicle, and plaintiffs thereby sustained bodily injuries. Plaintiffs brought action against defendants Burkhart and others for damages for their bodily injuries.
Defendant Oregon Mutual Insurance Company (OMIC) had issued a motor vehicle liability policy to the Burkharts. The policy had a single $50,000 bodily injury limit. Plaintiffs were entitled under the policy to PIP benefits to be paid by OMIC, and OMIC paid each plaintiff $5,000 for such benefits.
3
Plaintiffs settled their actions for damages. As a part of the settlement of those claims, OMIC contributed $40,000 to the total settlement figure. OMIC and plaintiffs agreed that the right to litigate whether OMIC must pay each of the plaintiffs an additional $5,000 to exhaust OMIC’s bodily injury coverage limits was preserved. This declaratory judgment action is to determine that issue.
The trial court gave judgment for plaintiffs for the sum of $5,000 each. On defendants’ appeal the Court of Appeals affirmed. We allowed review to consider the issue posed at the outset of this opinion.
We have discussed the statutory PIP benefits scheme
*52
in general in
Kessler v. Weigandt,
299 Or 38, 699 P2d 183 (1985). This case does not involve ORS 743.825 (interinsurer reimbursement). OMIC did not proceed under ORS 743.828 (claim and enforcement of lien upon recovery from tortfeasor or tortfeasor’s insurer) or ORS 743.830 (statutory method of recovery similar to subrogation).
4
Rather, OMIC contends that it is entitled under a proper interpretation of ORS 743.835 to the offset.
5
ORS 743.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit