Idaho Supreme Court April 10, 1985, 15490 (Bingham Memorial Hospital v. Idaho Department of Health and Welfare)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-04-1985
PER CURIAM:
The Department of Health & Welfare administers a federally funded “Medicaid” program to reimburse nursing homes for the costs of care to qualifying patients. The nursing homes were reimbursed for care provided to Medicaid patients by an
*347
amount equal to the lesser of reasonable costs of services or the “customary charge” for the services as required by federal and state regulation. The “customary charges” must be established by the amount charged to private patients of the general public for similar services.
Idaho counties subsidize the costs of care to private patients in county-operated nursing homes. The department and the county nursing homes were in agreement that both the amount subsidized (paid by the county) and the amount actually paid by the private patients be included in the “customary charge.” The amount of the county subsidy was not known until the end of the fiscal year. Therefore, in order to establish the charge to the private patient, the pro rata subsidy amount for each patient was posted to and credited off the individual patient’s account at the year’s end. This method was termed the “gross up” or “bulk up” method of accounting and was used by all the county nursing homes up until 1978 with no disallowances by the department. The department was concerned that the federal regulatory agency might view that the subsidy was not a “customary charge” and make a disallowance on the basis that it was inconsistent with the regulation. As a result of this concern, a pilot program at Caribou County Nursing Home devised the so-called “Caribou method” of accounting whereby an estimated subsidy amount was posted to and credited off each patient’s ledger on a monthly basis. In 1978 a department auditor orally advised a Bingham Memorial administrator to use the Caribou method, but no official written notice was given to the county nursing homes of this requirement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit