Oregon Supreme Court December 3, 1985, TC 1853; SC S31277 (House of Good Shepherd v. Department of Revenue)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-12-1985
*342
LENT, J.
The issue is whether a building owned by an incorporated religious organization and housing members of the organization, who live communally by the dictates of their religion, is exempt from real property taxation as property owned by a charitable institution “actually and exclusively occupied or used in the * * * charitable * * * work carried on by” the institution, ORS 307.130, or as “property used solely for * * * charitable * * * purposes by” the religious organization, ORS 307.140.
1
We hold it is exempt.
Plaintiff taxpayer appealed to defendant Department of Revenue from an assessment for the tax year 1981-82 of plaintiffs real property by the Director of the Multnomah County Department of Assessment and Taxation, ORS 305.275, claiming that the property was exempt pursuant to ORS 307.130 and 307.140. Defendant denied the appeal on the ground that the subject property itself is not used primarily for a charitable purpose but as a residence.
Plaintiff thereupon filed a complaint in the Oregon Tax Court, ORS 305.419, alleging that the property is exempt from taxation pursuant to ORS 307.130 and 307.140 because it
*343
is actually and exclusively occupied or used by plaintiff for a charitable purpose, specifically the advancement of religion. The matter was submitted to the Tax Court on stipulated facts. The court held that the property did not qualify for an exemption under either provision. We disagree.
Plaintiff is a nonprofit corporation, organized under ORS chapter 61 for “religious, benevolent, charitable and educational purposes.” The purpose of this corporation is the “advancement of the Catholic religion.” The members of this corporation, Roman Catholic nuns known as the Sisters of Good Shepherd, take vows of poverty, chastity, obedience and zeal for souls. They are required by the church to live and pray together as a community and observe the strict rules of their order.
The property at issue is located within the city of Portland.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit