West Virginia Supreme Court March 1, 1985, 16142 (State v. Franklin)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-1985

NEELY, Chief Justice:

Larry Dale Franklin was indicted by the grand jury of Berkeley County on 18 May 1982 under

W.Va.Code

17C-5-2(a) [1981] for the felony charge of driving under the influence of alcohol, resulting in death. The appellant was found guilty, and, accordingly, sentenced to 1-3 years, fined, and required to pay court costs. Because, under the circumstances of this case, the activities of courtroom spectators constituted reversible error, we reverse the circuit court’s holding and remand this case for a new trial.

On 5 March 1982, an aging 1969 Ford pickup truck collided with a Chevrolet Che-vette. The Chevrolet’s driver, Roger Moss, died of massive head injuries moments after the accident. The pickup truck, driven by the appellant, was actually owned by the wife of his companion that day, Richard Barnhart.

The appellant and Mr. Barnhart had spent a productive morning cutting and hauling wood. Mr. Barnhart testified that both the appellant and he had consumed over a six-pack of beer. Since Mr. Barn-hart felt rather tipsy, he had asked Mr. Franklin to drive the pickup truck home along State Route 9, a narrow road traversing the undulating hills around Martins-burg. The record indicates that the road was dry, the sun was shining, and the air was crisp.

Nobody witnessed this accident, but the evidence suggests that the appellant, driving eastbound, collided with the westbound vehicle driven by Mr. Moss on or near the center lane, forcing the smaller vehicle off the road. The damage to Mr. Moss’ vehicle was to the left, front fender, indicating that the appellant was considerably to the left of his side of the road. In any case, the appellant’s truck stopped only when it struck a second westbound vehicle driven by a Mr. Largent who had been following some distance behind Mr. Moss’ automobile.

This tragic accident was investigated initially by Trooper Ronald Jones who arrived, however, only after both Mr. Moss and Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.