Michigan Supreme Court November 7, 1985, 72407, (Calendar No. 6) (Demings v. City of Ecorse)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-11-1985
combined-opinion
423 Mich. 49 (1985) 377 N.W.2d 275 DEMINGS v. CITY OF ECORSE Docket No. 72407, (Calendar No. 6). Supreme Court of Michigan. Argued April 3, 1985. Decided November 7, 1985. Hurwitz, Karp, Hirschman & Wallach (by Martin Hirschman) for the plaintiff. Law Offices of Howard & Guido (by Barry L. Howard) for defendant Police Officers Association of Michigan. Amicus Curiae: Hiller, Larky & Hoekenga (by Daniel J. Hoekenga) for Michigan Education Association/NEA. LEVIN, J. The issue is whether the Michigan Employment Relations Commission has exclusive jurisdiction of fair representation actions brought under the public employment relations act. We hold that the circuit court has concurrent jurisdiction with the MERC. The PERA was modeled on the National Labor Relations Act. Under the NLRA, courts have concurrent jurisdiction with the National Labor Relations Board of fair representation actions. There are a number of reasons for concurrent jurisdiction. The right of fair representation was developed judicially by the United States Supreme Court. The right concerns substantive matters not within the expertise of the NLRB or the MERC and individual rights that might be better protected by *54 the courts. The right is intertwined in the judicial enforcement of collective bargaining agreements. We are not persuaded that an adequate reason for departing from the federal model in fair representation cases has been advanced. We hold that the circuit court has concurrent jurisdiction with the MERC and, thus, that the MERC does not have exclusive jurisdiction, and affirm the judgment of the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals affirmed the decision of the circuit court vacating the arbitration award, that the plaintiff, Alvin Demings, challenged in this action. That arbitration award may not properly be vacated unless the defendant Police Officers Association of Michigan breached its duty of fair representation.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit