Court of Appeals of North Carolina October 1, 1985, 844SC1323 (State v. Stallings)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-10-1985

EAGLES, Judge.

The dispositive question presented by this appeal is whether the State presented evidence that defendant was the perpetrator of the armed robbery sufficient to withstand defendant’s motion to dismiss.

I

The law governing questions of the sufficiency of the evidence in criminal cases is well established.

See State v. Earnhardt,

307 N.C. 62, 296 S.E. 2d 649 (1982); State

v. Bell,

65 N.C. App. 234, 309 S.E. 2d 464 (1983),

aff’d,

311 N.C. 299, 316 S.E. 2d 72 (1984) (per curiam). Briefly summarized, the law requires the State in a criminal prosecution to present to the jury substantial evidence of each element of the crime charged and of the accused’s identity as the perpetrator. The evidence, direct and cir

*190

cumstantial, is taken in the light most favorable to the State in determining its sufficiency; evidence which raises only a suspicion as to the accused’s identity does not suffice. While simply stated, these general principles remain difficult to apply.

II

Here the commission of the robbery was not disputed. On the issue of the identity of the perpetrator, the jury heard the following evidence from the State: Ms. King, the store clerk, testified that the robber walked into the store carrying a shotgun, with a mask over his face. She could only see his eyes, which were blue and distinctive. She recognized the robber’s voice as one she had heard before. Ms. King testified that defendant was a regular customer. She never positively identified defendant as the robber, however. She testified that defendant’s eyes were blue, but failed to identify them as the same distinctive eyes. Ms. King did not match defendant’s voice with the robber’s. She stated that the robber had an unusual walk, and that defendant had a “similar walk.” Ms. King positively identified the clothes and a shotgun found near the store after the crime as those used by the robber.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.