Idaho Court of Appeals September 4, 1985, 15878 (Marvin Centers v. Yehezkely)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-09-1985

PER CURIAM.

The question presented by this case is whether a real estate broker, Marvin Centers, is entitled to a commission for producing a ready, willing and able buyer for property owned by Uriel and Erela Yehezkely. Following a bench trial, a magistrate entered judgment for the broker. On appeal, the district court affirmed. The property owners have appealed again. For reasons set forth below we, too, affirm.

In the magistrate division and before the district judge, the property owners were represented by counsel. During those stages of the proceedings, they advanced two principal lines of defense against the broker’s claim. (1) They contended that certain prospective purchasers, including one Burke Jones, were orally excepted from the listing agreement and that the offer ultimately produced by the broker was from a corporation which in essence was Burke’s “alter ego.” (2) The owners also contended that the broker failed to perform under the listing agreement by timely presenting a valid full-price offer. In the instant appeal the owners, representing themselves, have presented five separately stated issues: (a) that there was no timely “full offer;” (b) that the document purporting to be such an offer was incomplete; (c) that the purported offer was not shown to the owners; (d) that the purported offer was somehow negated by an ex

*217

tension of the time deadline under the listing agreement; and (e) that the buyer produced by the broker actually was not willing to purchase the property on the terms indicated.

We begin by noting that the district court in this case functioned as an intermediate appellate court. It is well settled that when a second appeal is taken, the appellants may not raise issues in the higher court different from those presented in the intermediate court.

E.g., Davenport v. Stratton,

24 Cal.2d 4, 149 P.2d 4 (1944);

In re Gereke’s Estate,

165 Kan. 249, 195 P.2d 323 (1948);

Heron v. Gaylor,

49 N.M. 62, 157 P.2d 239 (1945);

Pappas v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.