Court of Appeals of North Carolina September 3, 1985, 859SC25 (Allen v. Allen)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-09-1985
ARNOLD, Judge.
Plaintiff contends that the trial judge erred in granting summary judgment in favor of the defendant on the basis of the common law doctrine of child immunity. More specifically, the plaintiff contends that 1) G.S. 1-539.21 abolished such immunity and 2) if the statute is interpreted as not to have affected such immunity, then the statute violates the equal protection and substantive due process requirements of the North Carolina and United States Constitutions.
Plaintiff first contends that the title of G.S. 1-539.21, “Abolition of parent-child immunity in motor vehicle cases,” should be used in construing the meaning of the statute. Plaintiff argues that the title implies total abolition of the parent-child immunity doctrine. It is true that the title of a statute may be considered when there is confusion in the wording of the text itself.
Toomey
*506
v. Lumber Co.,
171 N.C. 178, 88 S.E. 215 (1916). When the legislative intent is expressed clearly in the statutory language itself however, that language is controlling.
In re Forsyth County,
285 N.C. 64, 203 S.E. 2d 51 (1974). The text of G.S. 1-539.21 specifically states, “The relationship of parent and child shall not bar the right of action
by a minor child against a parent
for personal injury or property damages arising out of the operation of a motor vehicle owned or operated by such parent.” G.S. 1-539.21 (emphasis added). The text is very explicit and it, not the title, controls.
Further, this Court dealt with G.S. 1-539.21 in
Ledwell v. Berry,
39 N.C. App. 224, 249 S.E. 2d 864 (1978),
disc. rev. denied
296 N.C. 585, 254 S.E. 2d 35 (1979). There the statute was interpreted as abolishing only a parent’s immunity to suit. We still adhere to that position.
Plaintiff next contends that if G.S. 1-539.21 is found to abolish only parental immunity then the statute violates the substantive due process and equal protection requirements of the North Carolina and United States Constitutions.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit