Court of Appeals of North Carolina June 4, 1985, 8414SC671 (Holley v. Burroughs Wellcome Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-06-1985

combined-opinion

330 S.E.2d 228 (1985) Dianne HOLLEY, Individually, Greg L. Hinshaw, Guardian of the Estate of Ervin Lee Holley and Dianne Holley, Guardian of the person of Ervin Lee Holley v. BURROUGHS WELLCOME CO., A North Carolina Corporation and Ayerst Laboratories; A Division of American Home Products Corporation. No. 8414SC671. Court of Appeals of North Carolina. June 4, 1985. *232 McCain & Essen by Grover C. McCain, Jr., Chapel Hill, for plaintiffs-appellants. Newsom, Graham, Hedrick, Bryson, Kennon & Faison by E.C. Bryson, Jr., and Joel M. Craig, Durham, for defendant-appellee American Home Products Corp. Teague, Campbell, Conely & Dennis by C. Woodrow Teague, Raleigh, and Richard B. Conely, Fuquay Varina, for defendant-appellee Burroughs Wellcome. EAGLES, Judge. I Plaintiffs contend that it was error to allow defendants' motions for summary judgment because genuine issues of fact exist that must be submitted to the jury. We agree. Plaintiffs' specific contentions are (1) that there is an issue of fact as to the credibility of defendants' deposition witness, Dr. Hooper, that presents a jury question; (2) that Dr. Hooper was not the only person whose failure to recognize the symptoms of malignant hyperthermia was critical to the treatment of E.L. Holley; and (3) that there is a factual question as to the causal relationship between defendants' alleged failure to provide adequate warnings and the injury. If any of these specific contentions is valid, the court's entry of summary judgment for defendants was error. a. Our courts have often enunciated the principles governing summary judgment. They are well established in our law. "The party moving for summary judgment has the burden of establishing the lack of any triable issue of fact. His papers are carefully scrutinized and all inferences are resolved against him.... The court should never resolve an issue of fact." Kidd v. Early, 289 N.C. 343, 352, 222 S.E.2d 392, 399 (1976). See also Caldwell v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.