District Court, S.D. New York February 5, 1985, 84 Civ. 7565 (CBM) (G. & A. BOOKS, INC. v. Stern)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-02-1985
OPINION
MOTLEY, Chief Judge.
Plaintiffs, all in the business of selling and exhibiting sexually-explicit books, films and performances, sue to enjoin the destruction of their businesses by the Forty-Second Street Development Project. Plaintiffs claim that one of the motivations behind the Project, which will attempt to upgrade the Times Square area by building four large office towers, a hotel, and a merchandise mart, is to put them out of business and stifle distribution of sexually explicit, constitutionally protected material. They maintain that the Project’s blight findings with regard to adult uses are inadequate, that the Project constitutes a prior restraint, that it violates the First Amendment and the Equal Protection Clause by in effect zoning retroactively on the basis of content, and that the Project fails to use the least restrictive means in furthering whatever legitimate goals it
does
have. Plaintiffs seek a preliminary injunction to stop the planned condemnation of the buildings on Forty-Second Street in which their businesses operate.
*901
Defendants, myriad city and state officials with responsibility for the Project, and the private developers, respond that the Project is fully justified by the blight findings already made, that sexually explicit speech is not being singled out, that plaintiffs will not be denied access to the Project’s new commercial locations, and that even if they were, it would not give rise to a constitutional claim. Defendants move to dismiss on the merits and on the doctrines of abstention and comity. In addition, the private developer defendants argue that they are not proper parties to this action.
1
The case at bar requires the court to reconcile two broad strains of recent constitutional law. On the one hand, it has long been settled that the political branches of government have broad latitude in land use planning.
See Berman v. Parker,
348 U.S. 26, 75 S.Ct. 98, 99 L.Ed. 27 (1954).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit