Court of Special Appeals of Maryland March 7, 1985, 656, September Term, 1984 (Juiliano v. Lion's Manor Nursing Home)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-03-1985

*148

ROSALYN B. BELL, Judge.

The case before us presents yet again the question of the scope of judicial review regarding an administrative agency decision. In this instance, Lion’s Manor Nursing Home (Employer) challenged the Employment Security Administration’s

1

(ESA) award of unemployment insurance benefits to Mary T. Juiliano (Claimant). Although Employer did not attend the agency proceedings, it claimed a lack of substantial evidence because only one party presented information and witnesses. Employer also asserted that Claimant gave fraudulent testimony. Based on these allegations, the Circuit Court for Allegany County ordered the remand of the case to the agency to allow Employer to introduce its evidence.

Although Claimant’s appeal from the circuit court decision focuses primarily on procedural issues, a factual background of the case will prove helpful.

Claimant worked as a Licensed Practical Nurse and Charge Nurse at Lion’s Manor Nursing Home from January 1981 until March 25, 1982, when she voluntarily resigned. She filed a claim for unemployment insurance benefits, but a claims examiner of ESA found her ineligible on February 20, 1983. Claimant promptly appealed the denial of benefits. Written notice dated March 7, 1983, was sent to both Claimant and Employer informing them that a hearing would be held before an Appeals Referee at 9:00 a.m. on Wednesday, March 16, 1983, in the Hagerstown Office of ESA. The notice contained the following statement:

“THIS HEARING IS THE LAST STEP AT WHICH EITHER THE CLAIMANT OR THE EMPLOYER HAS THE ABSOLUTE RIGHT TO PRESENT EVIDENCE.

THE DECISION WILL BE MADE ON THE EVIDENCE PRESENTED. THE DECISION WILL AFFECT THE

*149

CLAIMANT’S CLAIM FOR BENEFITS, AND IT MAY AFFECT THE EMPLOYER’S CONTRIBUTION TAX RATE OR REIMBURSEMENT ACCOUNT.” (Emphasis and capitalization in original).

The hearing took place as scheduled but only Claimant appeared.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.