Missouri Court of Appeals June 4, 1985, 48211 (Carthen v. Jewish Hospital of St. Louis)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-06-1985
FRED E. SCHOENLAUB, Special Judge.
This action for damages arises out of an incorrect diagnosis of invasive adenocarci-noma by appellants, Marshall Poger, MD., and Joseph Lombardo, MD., pathologists and employees of appellant, The Jewish Hospital of St. Louis (hereinafter defendants), based on microscopic examination of esophageal biopsy specimens taken from
*789
respondent (hereinafter plaintiff) on December 5, 1979, at Jewish Hospital. A jury trial resulted in a verdict in favor of plaintiff in the sum of $2,500,000 upon which the court entered judgment. The judgment is affirmed.
On Thanksgiving Day 1979 plaintiff, John Carthen, Jr., experienced some difficulty in swallowing and a burning sensation in his chest. He went to Christian Hospital Northeast in St. Louis, where upper GI X-rays revealed an hiatus hernia with esophageal reflux. In early December 1979 his personal physician, Dr. Michael Orgell, referred him to Dr. Burton Shatz, a physician specializing in gastroen-terology. On December 5, 1979, at Jewish Hospital, Dr. Shatz performed an endoscopy, which involved the passing of a flexible tube with a light and lens on it through plaintiffs mouth in order to permit a visual examination of the interior of his esophagus and stomach. In this examination Dr. Shatz observed inflammation of the lower part of the esophagus just above the point where it enters the stomach, some ulceration and a stricture, or narrowing, of the opening into the stomach. Dr. Shatz testified that this type stricture is usually caused by scar tissue and had probably developed over a period of several months. No tumors were seen by Dr. Shatz. The stricture was benign appearing and there was no area suspected of being malignant. Dr. Shatz then took biopsies of the esophagus, a standard practice when there is an inflammation and stricture.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit