District Court, D. Oregon July 2, 1985, Civ. 84-6520 (Botefur v. Heckler)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-07-1985

OPINION AND ORDER

JAMES M. BURNS, District Judge.

Ernest Botefur seeks judicial review pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 405(g) of a decision of the Secretary of Health and Human Services (“Secretary”), denying his application for disability benefits. Because the Secretary’s decision failed to address certain key factual matters regarding transferability of skills, the case must be remanded for further proceedings.

FACTS

Botefur is a 60 year old male with a 12th grade education. (A.R. 14).

1

His vocationally relevant work history consists of work as a municipal maintenance man. (A.R. 11, 14). This job involved manual labor such as shoveling dirt and asphalt, welding, pouring cement, and operating heavy equipment. (A.R. 78).

On December 10, 1981 Botefur was injured on the job when he was struck by a backhoe boom, injuring his back. (A.R. 10, 92). A chiropractor diagnosed his condition at that time as back sprain and strain. (A.R. 98). X-rays taken in March, 1982 indicated lumbar scoliosis, with a possible interverterbral narrowing at L2-L3. A herniated disc was ruled out at that time. (A.R. 90, 99).

On April 1, 1982, Dr. Wichser, Botefur’s treating physician, noted restrictions in Botefur’s physical movements and stated that it was “quite clear that he is fairly disabled.” (A.R. 93). He made some improvement with medication and conservative treatment and on April 30 Botefur was released to return to “light duty” work. (A.R. 94).

On May 6, 1982, Botefur was examined by Dr. Degge for disability purposes. Dr. Degge found the claimant to be suffering from osteoarthritis, spondylosis and scoliosis, which were described as degenerative

*975

changes. Dr. Degge felt that the job injury, a pelvic contusion, had resolved itself and the patient’s condition was stationary. (A.R. 101). An EMG test on May 17 was normal, with nothing to suggest nerve damage. (A.R. 104, 105).

Botefur showed some improvement in motion by July, 1982, although he still complained of intermittent pain. (A.R. 96).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.