Court of Appeals of Iowa December 18, 1985, 84-1671 (Fears v. Iowa Department of Human Services)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-12-1985

HAYDEN, Judge.

Respondent agency appeals the judicial review decision reversing a denial of benefits, asserting that reliance upon a provider’s manual was not improper. We reverse and reinstate the agency determination.

Rebecca Fears, a Medicaid recipient, consulted an orthodontist concerning dental problems and was diagnosed as suffering from a malocclusion causing her lower jaw to come out of joint. Her request for payment of corrective treatment was denied following a hearing at which she presented evidence concerning the severity of her condition. The Department of Human Services found that, under a relevant administrative rule, the condition was not a “most handicapping malocclusion.”

In reaching this decision, the agency quoted the following language from a provider’s manual furnished to dentists participating in the Medicaid program:

8. Procedures which are not covered Medicaid dental program benefits:

a. Full mouth reconstruction procedures.

b. Cosmetic procedures and restorations solely for the improvement of esthetics.

c. Procedures, appliances or restorations (other than those for replacement of structure loss from caries) that are necessary to alter, restore, or maintain occlusion are NOT COVERED BENEFITS. These include:

(1) Increasing vertical dimension

(2) Replacing or stabilizing tooth structure loss by attrition

(3) Realignment of teeth

(4) Periodontal splinting

(5) Gnathologic recordings

(6) Equilibration

(7) Surgical treatment of disturbances of temporomandibular joint

(8) Services for the surgical treatment of prognathism or retrognathism

d. Treatment of incipient or non-active caries as demonstrated radiographically.

On judicial review, the district court reversed the agency decision on the ground that the provider’s manual was not a validly promulgated rule and that reliance on it was therefore improper. The agency has appealed, claiming that this determination was in error.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.