Court of Appeals of Wisconsin September 13, 1985, 84-1816 (Empire General Life Insurance v. Silverman)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-09-1985
SULLIVAN, J.
Morris L. Silverman (Silverman) appeals from a judgment declaring that Doucas Oldsmobile-Renault, Inc. (Doucas Olds) is beneficiary of an insurance
*273
policy issued by Empire General Life Insurance Company (Empire) on the life of Paul Doucas (Paul). Doucas Olds and Paul's widow, Sophia Doucas (Sophia), cross-appeal from that part of the judgment dismissing their cross-claim against Silverman for misrepresentation and breach of fiduciary duties. The issues are whether Paul performed an act that unequivocally indicated his intention to change the beneficiary under the subject policy from Silverman to Doucas Olds and, if so, whether Doucas Olds is equitably estopped from receiving the policy proceeds.
We hold as a matter of law that Paul effectively changed the beneficiary of the Empire policy from Silver-man to Doucas Olds in accordance with sec. 632.48(l)(b), Stats. We also hold that there is no reason to overturn the trial court's conclusion that Silverman's cross-claim, asserting his right to the insurance proceeds on some contractual or equity theory, was insufficiently proved. Nor did the trial court err in dismissing the cross-claim of Sophia and Doucas Olds against Silverman, since it was conditioned on a finding that Silverman was the beneficiary. Thus, we affirm the trial court's judgment in all respects.
The facts, as follows, are not in dispute. Paul was president and sole shareholder of Doucas Olds, a car dealership. Doucas Olds hired Silverman pursuant to a written contract in 1978. By its terms, the contract expired at the end of 1980. During the contract period, Silverman purchased an insurance policy on Paul's life, with Paul's permission, from Old Line Life in the amount of $100,000. Silverman was the owner and beneficiary of the Old Line Life policy and he paid the premiums.
In October, 1980, Paul arranged for Doucas Olds to purchase a $200,000 insurance policy on his life from Empire naming Silverman as beneficiary.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit