Louisiana Court of Appeal February 12, 1985, CA-2304 (Hernandez v. Schwegmann Giant Supermarkets)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-02-1985
464 So.2d 902 (1985) Carolina HERNANDEZ v. SCHWEGMANN GIANT SUPERMARKETS, et al. No. CA-2304. Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fourth Circuit. February 12, 1985. *903 Julian R. Murray, Jr., Romualdo Gonzalez of Murray, Murray, Braden, Landry & Gonzalez, New Orleans, for appellee. C. Monk Simons, III, New Orleans, for appellants. Before GULOTTA, BYRNES and CIACCIO, JJ. CIACCIO, Judge. Carolina Hernandez filed suit to recover damages resulting from her false detention and arrest by a security guard employed by Schwegmann Bros. Giant Supermarkets, Inc. A jury rendered judgment for the plaintiff and awarded her damages of $23,000. The defendants appeal this judgment and we affirm. The facts surrounding this incident are in conflict. On May 28, 1979 at approximately midday, the plaintiff and her twelve year old son were shopping at the defendant's supermarket located at 5300 Old Gentilly Road in New Orleans. According to the plaintiff, she selected several meat items during her shopping tour. She chose, among other items, two roasts. However, being of the opinion that she only needed the smaller roast, she returned the second roast to the meat freezer. She spent approximately 50 minutes shopping and checked out of aisle number 19 where she paid $160 for her purchases. According to Ms. Hernandez, shortly after making her purchases, she was confronted by Albert Roger, a security guard employed by the supermarket. Mr. Roger told the plaintiff that he needed to check a discrepancy and he then began to search Ms. Hernandez's grocery bags. Mr. Roger took a roast from the bag and instructed the plaintiff to go with him to the meat department, which she did. The roast was given to a woman in the meat department and she was instructed to weigh the roast. According to the plaintiff, the roast was weighed out of the presence of herself and the security guard. During this time, Mr. Roger was searching through the roast section of the meat counter, but he did not find anything.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit