Texas Supreme Court January 16, 1985, C-3475 (Anderson v. Gilliland)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-01-1985

WALLACE, Justice.

This will probate suit presents the sole issue of what constitutes the measure of reimbursement.

Terri L. Anderson is the surviving daughter and devisee under the will of Lawrence Gilliland, deceased. Cleo Gilli-land is the widow of Lawrence Gilliland and executrix of his estate.

At the date of the Gilliland’s marriage, Mrs. Gilliland owned certain real property. During the marriage the community expended $20,237.89 to build a home on the property. At the time of Mr. Gilliland’s death, this home had enhanced the separate property of Mrs. Gilliland by the sum of $54,000.00.

At trial Mrs. Anderson sought to have Mrs. Gilliland include one-half of the reimbursement due the community in the inventory of the estate of Lawrence Gilliland,

*674

because of the improvements the community made to the separate estate of Mrs. Gilliland. The trial court held that the proper measure of reimbursement was the enhanced value of Mrs. Gilliland’s separate property. It ordered Mrs. Gilliland to include in the inventory an amount equal to one-half of the enhancement resulting from the improvements.

The trial court also found that approximately one-third of the expenditures for the home was from Mrs. Gilliland’s separate funds. The court of appeals found that Mrs. Gilliland had not properly traced any separate funds into the home. 677 S.W.2d 105, appealing after remand 624 S.W.2d 243. Mrs. Gilliland did not appeal that finding.

The court of appeals further held that the proper measure of reimbursement to an estate which has expended funds to erect improvements on another estate is the enhancement of value to the receiving estate or the cost of the improvements, whichever is less. The court of appeals rendered judgment finding the amount of reimbursement due the community was one-half of the $20,237.89 expended, less one-half of the outstanding mortgage of $10,154.00. The community monies expended in building the home were proceeds from the mortgage.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.