Supreme Court of Arkansas February 25, 1985, 84-223 (Citizens Bank, Bentonville v. Chitty)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-02-1985

John I. Purtle, Justice.

A Benton County Circuit Court jury awarded appellee the sum of $8,000 on his complaint against the appellant for $9,000. On motion of appellant the trial court reduced the judgment by the amount appellee had collected from the drawer of the bad checks, Arthur L. Wagner, of Springfield, Missouri. Appellant appeals from the jury verdict on the ground that the trial court gave an erroneous instruction. The appellee cross appeals from the action of the trial court in reducing the judgment. We hold that the instruction was not prejudicial and that the court erred in reducing the jury verdict.

Arthur L. Wagner wrote appellee, Paul Chitty, three checks in 1981. All three were dishonored, the first two for insufficient funds and the third because the account was closed. The sequence of events is important in understanding the facts. The first check, in the amount of $4,750, was written on August 18, 1981, and deposited in appellee’s account in the appellant bank on August 25, 1981. The second check, in the amount of $4,500, was dated September 9, 1981. The first check was returned to the appellant bank on September 10, 1981, because of insufficient funds. The first check was sent back through banking channels for collection on September 11, 1981. On this same day Wagner wrote appellee a third check in the amount of $9,000. The second check was deposited by appellee in the appellant bank on September 14, 1981. The third check was deposited on September 16, 1981. On October 5, 1981, the appellant learned through its wire service that the second check was being returned for insufficient funds. The appellant also learned by wire service on September 24, 1981, that the drawer’s account had been closed. The first two checks were charged back to appellee’s account on October 7, 1981, and the third on October 15, 1981.

The appellee payee filed suit for damages against the appellant bank in the amount of $9,000 plus costs and prejudgment interest.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.