Court of Appeals of Minnesota August 6, 1985, C4-85-327 (Marriage of Lowe v. Lowe)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-08-1985
*66
OPINION
SEDGWICK, Judge.
This appeal is from an amended judgment and decree dissolving the Lowe’s 19-year marriage. Appellant contests the trial court’s valuation of respondent’s company, division of marital estate and allocation of marital debts. We affirm.
PACTS
The parties were married in 1966. During the marriage both completed advanced college degrees. Appellant has a masters degree in accounting, is a certified public accountant, and operates his own accounting firm. Respondent has a masters degree in vocational rehabilitation and is sole owner of her business, Rehabilitation Counselors, Inc. The parties own the building in which they each rent office space. The trial court awarded the business to each owner, the office building to appellant and the homestead to respondent.
ISSUE
Did the trial court err in valuation and division of marital assets and allocation of debts?
ANALYSIS
At trial each party’s expert valued respondent’s business. Respondent’s expert utilized a “net realizable value” approach. He reached a valuation of $35,000 by using the December 1983 book value of $45,372, adjusted for doubtful accounts ($1,060), uncollectible loans ($2,664), fixed assets ($6,203) and deferred incorporation costs ($208).
Appellant’s expert capitalized earnings of Rehabilitation Counselors, Inc. and arrived at a value of $234,000. He defined his approach as “the ability to have cash flow and income flow over a period of time.” He assumed yearly earnings of $36,000 and applied a 6.5% cap rate. He did not discount for lack of marketability. He assumed respondent would be required to sign a non-compete agreement for the metropolitan area if she sold the business.
Respondent owns 100% of the stock in her business providing job placement services to industrially injured clients. In 1978 this was a relatively new field with few competitors. Since 1981, many counselors have entered the field, including some of respondent’s employees who left to start their own business.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit