North Dakota Supreme Court August 15, 1985, Civ. 10807 (Emcasco Insurance Co. v. L & M Development, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-08-1985

GIERKE, Justice.

AID Insurance Company (AID) has appealed from a district court judgment in favor of the plaintiffs in an action to determine whether or not an insurance policy issued by AID to L & M Development, Inc., also known as Wyngate, Inc. (Wyngate), afforded coverage for a property damage claim against Wyngate. We affirm.

Wyngate hired independent contractors to construct townhomes which Wyngate later sold. After Wyngate sold the town-homes, shingles blown off the townhomes in a windstorm broke windows, damaged screens, and marred siding. Pursuant to homeowner’s insurance policies issued by the plaintiffs to the owners of the town-homes, plaintiffs compensated their insureds for the damages to the townhomes.

The plaintiffs brought a subrogation action against Wyngate, alleging that Wyn-gate breached express and implied warranties that the townhomes were constructed in a good workmanlike manner, reasonably fit for continued habitation, and free from defects. During the pendency of that action, Wyngate tendered to AID the defense of the action. AID denied coverage and refused to defend. Wyngate and the plaintiffs entered into a settlement agreement providing that the plaintiffs would collect damages, if any, only under the insurance policy issued by AID to Wyngate.

The trial court determined that the insurance policy afforded coverage for the underlying property damage claim and judgment was entered in favor of the plaintiffs. The issue on appeal is whether or not the comprehensive general liability insurance policy issued by AID to Wyngate affords coverage for the underlying property damage claim.

The insurance policy in issue provides:

“The company will pay on behalf of the insured all sums which the insured shall become legally obligated to pay as damages because of

Coverage A. bodily injury or

Coverage B. property damage

*910

to which this insurance applies, caused by an occurrence, ...

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.