Supreme Court of Iowa July 31, 1985, 84-823 (Farmers Savings Bank, Joice v. Gerhart)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-07-1985
SCHULTZ, Justice.
In this appeal we address issues arising from the simple foreclosure of a real estate mortgage. On March 8, 1983, the Farmers Savings Bank, Joice, Iowa, (bank), filed a petition in equity against defendants Charles F. Gerhart, Penelope J. Gerhart, and Chaspen Corporation. The bank was seeking a money judgment, the foreclosure of a real estate mortgage, and the appointment of a receiver. The same day Elwood Norstrud was appointed receiver by an ex parte order of the district court. On May 26, 1983, a judgment and decree was rendered granting the bank a money judgment of $38,566.00 and foreclosing the mortgage against the real estate. A nunc pro tunc order dated June 28, 1983, increased the amount of the judgment to $52,928.63. No issues arise concerning the amount of the judgment or the foreclosure decree.
The events causing the controversy between the parties, while not complex, are indeed unusual and peculiar. Before the foreclosure action was commenced a fire gutted the residence located on the mortgage real estate. The damaged property was insured and under the terms of the mortgage the bank was included in the loss payable clause of the policy. While the record in this case is sparse, it appears the insurance company refused to settle with its insured, the defendants in this case. At the same time, because of other contacts between the parties which included the bank filing criminal charges against Charles Gerhart, the relationship between the bank and defendants degenerated. Although the foreclosure action did not address the rights to insurance proceeds, a receiver was appointed to collect the “insurance from premises” and apply that amount “as per section 654.14 of the Code.”
1
At the time the foreclosure judgment and decree was entered, the insurance company had not settled the fire loss and the court did not address the impact of settlement on the judgment.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit