District Court, N.D. Illinois March 27, 1985, 83 C 2283 (Levka v. City of Chicago)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-03-1985
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER
SHADUR, District Judge.
Maria Levka (“Levka”) moves for an award of attorneys’ fees for her lawyers’ services on the appeal in this strip search case against the City of Chicago (the “City”). For the reasons stated in this memorandum opinion and order, her motion is denied.
Because the City had admitted the police strip search of Levka had violated her constitutional rights, the jury trial in this Court was limited to damages. From the evidence and the closing argument of Levka’s lawyers, the jury was persuaded to award her $50,000. Though this Court viewed that judgment as substantially higher than it would have awarded had it been the trier of fact in a bench trial, its respect for the jury function led it to deny the City’s post-trial motions. But our Court of Appeals disagreed and ordered Levka to accept a remittitur reducing the judgment to $25,000 or alternatively to try the case anew (of course the appeal, like the trial, had been limited to the damage issue). 748 F.2d 421 (7th Cir.1984).
1
This Court originally awarded, and Levka has already been paid, $24,475 for her lawyers’ fees at the trial stage.
Roe v. City of Chicago,
586 F.Supp. 513 (N.D.Ill.1984) (this Court published that opinion under the “Roe” pseudonym because Levka’s counsel had asked that this Court’s criticisms of their fee request of nearly twice that amount should not be ascribed to them publicly). No appeal was taken from that award by either litigant.
Now Levka urges her lawyers should be compensated for their work on the City’s appeal on the theory she was “the prevailing party in the litigation as a whole” (Pl.Mem. 1). But the myth of the philosopher’s stone—of transmuting base metal into gold—has long since been exploded. Levka has been paid in full—or more
2
—for the fact her lawyers prevailed
*199
for her in the trial court to the tune of the original $50,000 verdict. No matter how Levka slices it, she is worse off now,
after
the appeal, than
before
it.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit