Kentucky Supreme Court November 21, 1985 (Kirchner v. Riherd)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-11-1985

combined-opinion

702 S.W.2d 33 (1985) Michael P. KIRCHNER, Movant, v. John RIHERD, Respondent. Supreme Court of Kentucky. November 21, 1985. Rehearing Denied February 6, 1986. E. Patrick Moores, Fowler, Measle & Bell, Lexington, for movant. Charles A. Taylor, Taylor, Elam & McConnell, Lexington, for respondent. STEPHENSON, Justice: The trial court dismissed Riherd's complaint seeking damages for personal injuries. The trial court relied upon the rule of law that causes of action shall not be split. The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court on the theory there was no splitting of a cause of action. We granted discretionary review and reverse. Riherd sued Kirchner in circuit court for personal injuries suffered in an automobile accident. Kirchner filed a motion to dismiss, pleading res judicata as a result of Riherd's splitting his cause of action and later filed motion for summary judgment. Kirchner stated as grounds for dismissal that Riherd had previously filed an action against him in the small claims division of the district court for property damage and loss of use of an automobile, arising out of the same accident. The trial court entered summary judgment for Kirchner on the ground that the action in district court barred his claim for personal injuries. The Court of Appeals, in reversing the trial court, recognized the doctrine of prohibition against splitting a cause of action, but distinguished this case on its facts. Strangely enough, the Court of Appeals based its decision on the $1,000 jurisdictional limit for the district court, reasoning that since Riherd's claim for personal injuries and medical expenses far exceeded the $1,000 limit, he could not have filed these claims in the district court at the same time. As a further ground, the Court of Appeals expressed the opinion that the issue of negligence was not presented. Riherd filed a small claims complaint in district court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.