Tennessee Supreme Court February 11, 1985 (State v. Hodges)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-02-1985

OPINION

FONES, Justice.

In January 1983, defendant was charged in a multiple count indictment with tampering with utility metering devices. His lawyer appeared before the trial judge on February 22, 1983, asking for a trial date for the misdemeanors with which defendant was charged. The trial judge informed defendant’s counsel on that occasion that he would not “put up with his [defendant’s] foolishness” and if “he comes in here dressed like a chicken, I am going to order him out of here under guard.”

On June 28, 1983, defendant appeared for trial, with the same counsel, and to say that he was dressed “like a chicken” as the trial judge had anticipated, is a mild description of the outrageous attire in which defendant barely covered himself.

1

The trial judge first addressed defendant’s attorney and asked him to have his client appear in proper clothes. Defendant’s attorney responded by informing the court that defendant wished to exercise his right of “freedom of expression.” The trial judge then directed his remarks to defendant and ordered him to put on “regular clothes” for the trial scheduled that day.

*172

The trial judge sought a yes or no answer, but defendant responded with the following assertion:

“This is a spiritual attire and it is my religious belief and I have never worn anything else in court but this when I am on trial.”

Whereupon, the trial judge found him to be in contempt of court, revoked his bond, and ordered him committed to jail for ten days or until he agreed to appear for trial in proper clothes.

Defendant’s counsel asked the court to allow him to “build a record for appeal” which was denied. Motions were filed the following day, June 29, 1983, on behalf of defendant for a new trial, for reconsideration of the finding of contempt, and for bail pending appeal. At the hearing held on that same day, defense counsel again sought an evidentiary hearing on the issue of defendant’s religious belief which was again denied.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.