District Court, S.D. Florida March 30, 1985, 81-8072-Civ (DeWeese v. Town of Palm Beach)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-03-1985
ORDER
ROETTGER, District Judge.
This case could appropriately be titled— with apologies to Neil Simon—Bareback in the Park. Essentially, it involves an assault by Plaintiff, a lawyer, upon the Town of Palm Beach’s ordinance which proscribes running or jogging without a shirt, or top, except on the beach or private property. Plaintiff assails this as violating his first amendment rights, as well as on other bases.
The case has had an extremely complicated procedural background and, if one looks for an aggravating cause of court congestion, this case could be a splendid illustration.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On November 19,1979, Allen J. DeWeese (“DeWeese”), an attorney, was stopped by a police officer and issued a Notice to Appear for Indecent Exposure—Lewdness for running on a public jogging and bicycle trail in the Town of Palm Beach (the “Town”) clad in running shorts but with the upper part of his body uncovered.
DeWeese is an adult male resident of the Town of Palm Beach, a Florida municipal corporation located within the Southern District of Florida. DeWeese was verbally warned by the officer on numerous occasions, and was issued one prior written warning.
State Court
Proceedings
1
Prior to trial in state court under the first ordinance (Ordinance 21-48) as a criminal defendant, DeWeese filed a motion to dismiss on various constitutional grounds. After an evidentiary hearing, the Palm Beach County judge granted DeWeese’s motion to dismiss and struck the ordinance as unconstitutional.
The Town appealed and the Appellate Court remanded so that the constitutionality of the ordinance could be considered at a further evidentiary hearing, which was held before a different Palm Beach County judge. The Town presented testimony that the first ordinance was an adjunct to other Town regulations which assisted in the preservation of the Town’s tradition, heritage and quality of life pursuant to the
*974
Town’s goals as set forth in its Comprehensive Plan.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit