Court of Appeals of Minnesota May 7, 1985, C1-85-141 (Drewes v. Levine)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-05-1985

*720

OPINION

POPOVICH, Chief Judge.

Respondent previously appealed from the denial of his petition for discharge from commitment.

Drewes v. Levine,

352 N.W.2d 456 (Minn.Ct.App.1984). We reversed for lack of factual findings, established the burden of proof to obtain discharge, and remanded. The parties then agreed a new petition for discharge would be heard de novo. The appeal panel ordered respondent discharged because he was not mentally ill and his dangerousness did not result from mental illness. We reverse and remand.

FACTS

Drewes, a 49 year old man, was committed to the St. Peter Security Hospital in August 1981 as manic depressive and chemically dependent. He petitioned the Commissioner of Public Welfare (now Human Services) for discharge. The petition was denied and the supreme court appeal panel affirmed, retaining jurisdiction for one year to monitor placement. We reversed concluding Drewes must meet the statutory criteria for discharge and that the panel must make factual findings in support of their decision.

A new petition for discharge dated July 18, 1984 was heard on August 31, 1984. The panel, in a split decision, found (a) Drewes was not mentally ill, (b) that he may not have been mentally ill when committed, (c) that he suffers from a character disorder (anti-social personality), and (d) he abuses chemicals. The appeal panel concluded his dangerousness did not result from mental illness and ordered discharge. The committing county appeals, arguing the statutory criteria for discharge should have been considered.

ISSUES

1. Does a nonparticipating committing county have standing to appeal a discharge order?

2. Was respondent properly discharged when the appeal panel concluded he was not dangerous as a result of mental illness?

ANALYSIS

1. A patient committed as mentally ill and dangerous may file a petition for discharge to be heard by the special review board. Minn.Stat. § 253B.18, subd. 5 (1984).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.