Court of Appeals of Minnesota January 29, 1985, C4-84-723 (Garner v. Todd)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-01-1985
OPINION
RANDALL, Judge.
This appeal arises from a directed verdict entered in a personal injury action on behalf of the defendant Elmer Todd. Appellants argue that the presence of disputed facts prevents the application of a directed verdict.
We affirm.
FACTS
Appellant Gregory Garner was employed as an operator of a tractor-trailer unit by Wayne Schmidt. Schmidt was involved in the sale of farm implements. As part of his business, Schmidt used the tractor-trailer to haul implements. Pursuant to a written agreement, Schmidt leased the tractor-trailer from respondent Elmer Todd, the title holder and owner, and Schmidt’s father-in-law.
After obtaining the tractor-trailer unit from respondent Todd, Schmidt modified the trailer portion to accommodate bigger loads. In June or July of 1979, Schmidt added a “top deck” to the trailer. Todd took no part in the alteration. On July 21, 1980, on a long distance trip, appellant Garner noticed that the top sideboard on the upper deck had come loose. He stopped in Austin, Minnesota, climbed to the top deck and attempted to reposition sideboards. He fell from the upper deck to the ground and suffered injuries.
Appellant brought an action against Todd, the owner of the tractor-trailer, for damages arising from injuries sustained in the fall from the trailer (worker’s compensation was not in issue). At a jury trial and after evidence from both parties had been submitted, the trial court directed a verdict in favor of respondent Todd.
ISSUE
Did the court properly direct a verdict for defendant in the negligence action?
ANALYSIS
A directed verdict is appropriate only in exceptional cases.
A motion for a directed verdict presents a question of law regarding the sufficiency of the evidence to raise a fact question for the jury’s decision.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit