Court of Appeals of Minnesota January 22, 1985, C7-84-1381 (Fahy v. Templin)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-01-1985
OPINION
NIERENGARTEN, Judge.
Ronald Fahy recovered a jury verdict of $78,000 in a personal injury action against Charles Templin and the City of Minneapolis. The trial court offset the verdict by the no-fault benefits Fahy had received for lost income and for the medical expense found by the jury to be necessarily incurred by Fahy, which amount was less than that actually paid. Templin and Minneapolis appeal, contending the trial court erred in not deducting the full amount of medical benefits paid to Fahy. We affirm.
FACTS
A Minneapolis city truck driven by Charles Templin struck Ronald Fahy’s car. Fahy’s insurer paid him no-fault benefits of $40,000 for medical expenses and $20,000 for lost wages on two auto policies maintained by Fahy.
Templin and Minneapolis admitted liability and the issue of damages was submitted to the jury. The jury found that Fahy
*159
incurred $18,000 of necessary medical expenses as a result of the accident and an award of $78,000 would fairly compensate him for injuries and damages, including medical and hospital expenses and loss of earnings.
Templin and Minneapolis then requested the court, pursuant to Minn.Stat. § 65B.51, subd. 1 (1982), to deduct the $60,000 no-fault benefits received from the $78,000 verdict. The trial court offset the verdict by $20,000 for lost income benefits and $18,000 for necessary medical expense benefits, but refused to deduct the additional $22,000 paid for medical expenses. Temp-lin and Minneapolis appeal.
ISSUE
Where no-fault medical expense benefits paid to an injured person exceed those found reasonably necessary by a jury, should the excess payment be deducted from the total jury award?
ANALYSIS
Templin and Minneapolis contend that Minn.Stat. § 65B.51, subd. 1 (1982) requires the full amount of medical expense benefits paid to Fahy by his insurer to be deducted from the verdict against Templin and Minneapolis. Anything less, they argue, results in Fahy being overcompensated for his medical expenses.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit