Mississippi Supreme Court August 7, 1985, 54914 (Overstreet v. Allstate Ins. Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-08-1985

474 So.2d 572 (1985) Marion Blue OVERSTREET, Maxine Blue Gonzales, Faye Blue Thornton, W.M. Blue and Michael Dean Blue v. ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY. No. 54914. Supreme Court of Mississippi. August 7, 1985. *573 Leonard B. Melvin, Jr., Sarah L. Entrekin, Melvin & Melvin, Laurel, for appellant. Harold W. Melvin, Patricia Melvin, Laurel, for appellee. Before WALKER, P.J., and PRATHER and SULLIVAN, JJ. SULLIVAN, Justice, for the Court: Harmon S. Blue owned three vehicles, all of which were covered by an uninsured motorist insurance policy issued by Allstate Insurance Company. Blue paid separate premiums for each vehicle. In February, 1980, while driving his own vehicle, Blue was struck by an uninsured motorist and he died as a result of the injuries from that accident. Blue is survived by his widow, Lillie Mae Blue, and seven children. None of the children resided in the Blue family home. Blue's Allstate policy had a $10,000 limitation as to "each person" and a $20,000 limitation as to "each accident". By aggregating, or "stacking", these limitations become $30,000 "per person", and $60,000 "per accident". Allstate's representative, John McCoy, paid $65,000 to Lillie Mae Blue. All of the "per accident" benefits due from Allstate were paid out, although no estate was opened and McCoy apparently never made a serious effort to determine who the heirs of Harmon Blue might be. On April 27, 1982, appellants, five of the seven Blue children, sued Allstate in Jones County Circuit Court, claiming they were entitled to share in the insurance proceeds and further were entitled to punitive damages because Allstate's failure to recognize their legal rights constituted bad faith. Appellants' theory of recovery is as follows: 1. Mississippi Code Annotated § 83-11-103 (Supp. 1984), of the Uninsured Motorist Coverage Act, and Mississippi Code Annotated § 63-15-43 (Supp.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.