United States Bankruptcy Court, C.D. California September 18, 1985, Bankruptcy Nos. LA 83-22062-JD to LA 83-22064-JD and LA 83-23421-JD, Adv. No. LA 84-50711-JD (Englander Co. v. City Mattress of Amherst, Inc. (In Re United States Bedding Co.))
Also known as
United States · · · 18-09-1985
MEMORANDUM OF DECISION
JAMES R. DOOLEY, Bankruptcy Judge.
In this action plaintiff seeks to recover $44,820.00 plus interest for goods sold and delivered or alternatively, on an “account stated” or an “open book account”. At trial it was stipulated on the record that during the period from September 26, 1983 through October 27, 1983 plaintiff manufactured and shipped to the defendant merchandise valued and invoiced at $43,910.00; and plaintiff failed to prove that it shipped merchandise to the defendant in any greater amount. Therefore, defendant is liable to plaintiff for $43,910.00, plus pre-judgement interest, unless defendant prevails, in whole or in part, on its affirmative defenses of setoff. Two basic issues are presented:
1. To what extent did the defendant establish the debts which it seeks to use as setoffs?
2. To what extent is defendant barred by 11 U.S.C. § 553(a)(3) from using these debts as setoffs?
Extent To Which Defendant Established Debts
The principal debt which defendant seeks to use as a setoff resulted from an agreement reached sometime during August 1983 between officials of plaintiff and officials of defendant. In substance, the agreement provided that defendant was entitled to credits of $13,000.00; but that in order to induce defendant to resume doing business with plaintiff, these credits would be doubled to $26,000.00.
1
The parties also
*877
agreed that a discount of 15% would be given to defendant if defendant did certain advertising. While the record sufficiently establishes the agreement between the parties, it does not show that the defendant in fact did the required advertising. Therefore, a debt of $26,000.00 based upon the agreement has been established; however, the evidence is insufficient to establish any debt based upon the agreed 15% discount for advertising.
The record also fails to prove a debt owed to defendant for servicing merchandise purchased from plaintiff (see second affirmative defense and counterclaim).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit