Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama March 26, 1985 (Jenkins v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-03-1985

Richard Jay Jenkins, the appellant, was indicted for first and second degree rape and for indecent exposure. The respective sentences were fifteen years', ten years', and twelve months' imprisonment. I Jenkins was charged in a three-count indictment with the first degree rape of Sheila R., the second degree rape of Laura S., and indecently exposing himself to Judy S. He contends that the joinder was prejudicial and denied him a fair trial. This Court agrees. Jenkins was tried on the 19th of March, 1984. Alabama's Rules of Criminal Procedure concerning joinder, consolidation and severance became effective on March 1, 1983. The Attorney General argues that the three offenses were properly joined under Rule 15.3 (a)(i), A.R.Cr.P.Temp., allowing the joinder of offenses in an indictment if they "are of the same or similar character." This ground of joinder has caused considerable difficulty because of the obvious danger of prejudice to the accused. C. Wright, Federal Practice And Procedure: Criminal 2d § 143 (1982): "Decisions applying the `same or similar character' test have generally failed `to provide criteria which would provide guidance as to the precise scope of this rule.' The view seems to be gaining acceptance, however, that the most important consideration is whether evidence of one offense would have been admissible at a trial of the other offense." Federal Practice at § 143. Although there may exist some ground for arguing the joinder of the rape of Laura S. and the indecent exposure to Judy S., as the victims were sisters living in the same household, there is not even the contention that the rape of Sheila R. would have been admissible at the trial of the other offenses. Ex parte Killough,438 So.2d 333 (Ala. 1983). The evidence does not support any assertion that the three sexual offenses were part of a common scheme or plan. Sheila R. was a married adult and was not related to Jenkins, although she knew him. At approximately 10:00 A.M.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.