Supreme Court of Louisiana June 28, 1985, 85-C-0100 (Argus v. Scheppegrell)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-06-1985

472 So.2d 573 (1985) Billie J. Argus, Wife of/and Herbert ARGUS v. William C. SCHEPPEGRELL, Jr., M.D. No. 85-C-0100. Supreme Court of Louisiana. June 28, 1985. Rehearing Denied September 9, 1985. Douglas A. Kewley, Bruce A. North, Malony, Nolan, North & Reiss, Metairie, *574 William J. Scheffler, III, Gretna, for plaintiff-applicant. Dominic J. Gianna, John D. Person, Hammett, Leake & Hammett, New Orleans, for defendant-respondent. LEMMON, Justice. We granted certiorari in this pre-comparative fault case to determine whether a physician who wrongfully supplied prescriptions for controlled dangerous substances in excessive amounts to a teenaged patient who was a known drug addict, even after promising the patient's mother that he would not supply the patient any more prescriptions for drugs, should be relieved of liability for the patient's death on the basis that the patient was contributorily negligent by taking a lethal overdose of drugs. We hold that because of the disparity of positions in the relationship between a trained and licensed physician and a nineteen-year old uneducated patient whose drug addiction was known to the physician, and because of the vastly different duty required of each party under the circumstances, the patient's reasonably expected conduct did not constitute an absolute bar to her parents recovery for her wrongful death. The patient's conduct cannot be, at the same time, both the foreseen risk which imposes the duty on the physician and the defense which totally excuses the physician's breach of that very duty. Under such circumstances, the physician can only avoid liability completely (even in a pre-comparative fault case) by refusing to supply prescriptions at all.[1] Plaintiffs' daughter, Cindy Argus, consulted Dr. William Scheppegrell in December, 1975. She was a few months beyond her eighteenth birthday, and he had been in private practice for nineteen years.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.