Supreme Court of Pennsylvania August 9, 1985, 03113 (Commonwealth v. Finn)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-08-1985

McEWEN, Judge:

We here consider an appeal by the Commonwealth from an order which discharged appellee following a preliminary hearing held before a Common Pleas Court Judge.

See Commonwealth ex rel. Riggins v. Superintendent of Philadelphia Prisons,

438 Pa. 160, 263 A.2d 754 (1970). The hearing court held that the Commonwealth had failed to establish a

prima facie

case of conspiracy to distribute controlled substances and, as a result, discharged appellant. While the distinguished Judge Clinton W. Smith has in his able opinion provided a quite persuasive rationale for his ruling, we are, nonetheless, compelled to disagree and, therefore, reverse and remand.

*574

It must be preliminarily observed that such orders as the one we review are not ordinarily appealable since the defendant is normally subject to rearrest. “We have long held that the conclusion of a committing magistrate that the prosecution has failed to establish a

prima facie

case is not a final determination of guilt [or innocence] such as an acquittal. The prosecution may bring the matter before any other officer empowered to hold a preliminary hearing.”

Commonwealth v. Prado,

481 Pa. 485, 487, 393 A.2d 8, 9 (1978). Appellee was not subject to rearrest, however, because the applicable statute of limitations had expired by the time the order was entered. The order discharging appellee must be viewed, therefore, as a final order from which an appeal may properly be taken.

See Commonwealth v. Prado, supra; Praisner v. Stocker,

313 Pa.Super. 332, 336, 459 A.2d 1255, 1258 (1983).

Having determined that the order discharging appellee was a final and appealable order, we proceed to determine whether the trial court correctly concluded that a

prima facie

case had not been established. The facts here are not in dispute. Whether a

prima facie

case has been established is, therefore, a question of law.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.