Massachusetts Appeals Court February 11, 1985 (Robert Trent Jones, Inc. v. Canter)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-02-1985

Armstrong, J.

In 1972 the plaintiff, a designer of golf courses, did a layout for a course in Adams, at the foot of Mount Greylock, which was to be known as the Greylock Glen Golf Course. The plaintiff was paid $3,000 for the design; it asserts, on a contract claim, that it is entitled to more. It named several defendants but recovered a verdict ($65,000, reduced

*322

by remittitur to $40,000) only against Canter. The case is here on Canter’s appeal from the ensuing judgment. Canter’s position is (1) that no contract was ever entered into; (2) that the contract alleged by the plaintiff, if found to have come into existence, was fully satisfied by the $3,000 paid; and (3) that, in any event, the alleged contract was, as matter of law, with a corporation named Elco Resort Developers, Inc., of which Canter was “a principal officer,” and not with Canter in his individual capacity.

The plaintiff was first approached in the autumn of 1971, by one Dragone, who was president of Planning Associates, Inc., a planning consultant located in Springfield. Rulewich, an employee of the plaintiff, outlined to Dragone the price for the plaintiff’s services: $3,000 for the preparation of a “route plan” and, if the plan should be used, ten percent of the construction cost (in connection with which the plaintiff would do the working drawings and supervise the construction). The route plan would remain the plaintiff’s property and could not be used by the owner without employing the plaintiff for the additional services. If the owner did not use the route plan his sole obligation would be to pay the $3,000.

In December, 1971, Dragone brought together on the Adams site Rulewich, Canter, a master planner, and an architect; these men discussed plans for a year-round recreational complex, including a hotel and facilities for skiing and golf.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.