Court of Special Appeals of Maryland December 16, 1985, 472, September Term, 1985 (Hart v. Miller)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-12-1985

*621

JAMES S. GETTY, Judge,

Specially Assigned.

The right to be wrong without incurring reversal is not absolute. Rosenberg,

Judicial Discretion of the Trial Court,

22 Syracuse Law Review 635 (1971).

The sole issue presented by this appeal is whether the trial judge abused his discretion in dismissing a plaintiffs case for counsel’s failure to answer interrogatories in a timely manner. We shall reverse and remand this case for imposition of a less onerous penalty.

A review of the record establishes that on May 15, 1980, Paul M. Hart, one of the appellants herein, sustained a serious physical injury when the motorcycle he was operating collided with an automobile being driven by Kenneth Allen Miller, one of the appellees, who was a minor at the time of the accident. The collision occurred at the crest of a hill on Persimmon Lane in Calvert County. Appellant sustained seventeen facial fractures requiring extensive corrective and reconstructive surgery. At the time of trial his special damages included medical expenses of $54,000 and lost wages amounting to $36,000.

Appellant filed suit on May 13, 1983, alleging negligence by the driver, Kenneth Allen Miller, Jr., and further charging Miller’s parents with negligent entrustment of the vehicle to their son. On June 20, 1983, the appellees filed general issue pleas and included therewith two sets of Interrogatories that appellant Hart and his wife were directed to answer.

1

It is the failure to respond to these Interrogatories, after being directed by the trial court to answer within a specified time, that prompted the trial court to dismiss the case. We shall relate the chronology of events leading to the dismissal.

According to the appellees, the first inquiry concerning the Answers to Interrogatories took place on August 29,

*622

1983, in a conversation between secretaries for the two law firms.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.